Interactive Lessons

Approximate solutions: trial and improvement

Lecture notes

Definition

Trial and improvement

A method to find an approximate solution of an equation: try a number for x, look at the result and improve the guess, again and again.
2462030xy39
Example
: try . is too low try a bigger x
246104050xy30525
Definition

Too low and too high

Put the trial into the left side and compare it with the right side. Smaller: too low. Bigger: too high. Equal: you have found a solution. too low, too high
246102030xy925
Example
, trial :, smaller than 100 too low
26100150200xy464
Definition

Sign change

When one trial is too low and the next one is too high (or the other way round), the solution lies between them. That is why the method works.
xx²20416<525>
Example
: is Low, is High.Low High: the solution is between 5 and 6
2468204060xy3042
Rule

Whole numbers first

Try whole numbers until Low turns into High. For : is too low and is too high, so the solution is between 4 and 5.
xx²2039<416<525>636>
Example
: is Low, is High.The solution is between 8 and 9
78910
Rule

Digit by digit

Between 4 and 5 try 4.1, 4.2, … until Low turns into High: between 4.4 and 4.5. Then try the second decimal. Every step makes the interval ten times smaller.
44.554.44.5×10
Example
, between 8 and 9: is Low, is High.The solution is between 8.3 and 8.4
88.598.38.4×10
Rule

Test the middle

Between 4.4 and 4.5 you do not yet know if the answer to 1 decimal place is 4.4 or 4.5. Test the middle, 4.45: if it is too low, the solution is in the upper half and you round up.
xx²204.419.36<4.4519.8025<4.520.25>
Example
, between 8.3 and 8.4: test the middle. is too low upper half,
8.38.358.4
Rule

Use a table

Write every trial in a table: x, the left side and Low or High. Keep the closest Low and the closest High: the solution is between them.
xx²2039<525>416<4.520.25>
Example
: keep the closest Low and the closest High. Low, High, Low: between 3.5 and 4
xx³+x60330<468>3.546.375<
Rule

Table and graph

On a graph both sides are curves. Where they cross, the two sides are equal. A sign change in the table is the same as the curves passing each other.
123451020xy
Example
: , Low High: the curves cross between and
1234246810xy
Rule

How many decimals

For 1 decimal place the interval must be 0.1 wide, for 2 decimal places 0.01, and always test the middle at the end. 1 decimal place, 2 decimal places
44.554.44.454.5×10
Example
to 2 decimal places: interval 0.01 wide. Low, High; middle Low
8.368.378.37
Tip

Start with the middle

Once you have two numbers around the solution, try the number in the middle: the interval gets half as wide, whatever the equation.
1÷21/2÷21/4
Example
is between 5 and 6. Try the middle, 5.5: is Low between 5.5 and 6, half as wide
55.56
Tip

Look at the sizes

If the left side is much closer to the right side for one of the two numbers, the solution is probably closer to that number.
362564125100
Example
: is 16 away, is only 1 away.The solution is probably close to 9:
161648180
Tip

Check your answer

Put your answer back in the equation: both sides should be almost equal. The answer is an approximation, so they will not be exactly equal.
1920210.25✔
Example
, answer . Put it back: ✔ (almost equal, not exactly)
697071720.56✔
Watch out!

Rounding too soon

Between 4.4 and 4.5 is not an answer to 1 decimal place. Test the middle first, or you may round the wrong way.
4.44.454.5??✘
Example
: Low, High.✘ ✔ High
3.13.153.2✔
Watch out!

Too low and too high mixed up

Look at the left side, not at x. In a bigger x gives a smaller left side.
48121620244812162024xy105
Example
, trial : is too high.✘ smaller x: ✔ bigger x:
4812164812xy6✘✔
Watch out!

Only one solution

has two solutions: about 4.47 and about −4.47. Look at negative numbers too.
102030xy−4.474.47
Example
:✘ only ✔ and : also
−66204060xy−6.76.7
Watch out!

Stopping early

Two numbers that are 1 apart are not an answer to 1 decimal place. Keep going until the interval has the width you need.
1✘0.1✔
Example
to 1 decimal place: Low, High.✘ stop at ✔ go on: Low, High
67✘6.36.4✔
Special case

An exact solution

gives exactly . If a trial makes both sides equal, you are finished: no rounding.
261030xy16416
Example
, trial : exactly equal, : no rounding
24650200250xy1255125
Special case

Exactly in the middle

has the solution 2.45, exactly in the middle of 2.4 and 2.5. A solution exactly in the middle is rounded up: 2.5.
xx²6.00252.45.76<2.456.0025=2.56.25>
Example
: Low, High.Middle: exactly equal round up,
5.25.255.3
Special case

No solution

never has Low turning into High: the left side is never negative, so the equation has no solution.
−4−224−8−44812xy✘
Example
: , : always High.The left side is at least 5, never 1 no solution
−22510xy1✘
Special case

Real life

Choose the sensible answer: a width is positive, and when interest is paid once a year you must wait whole years.
−8−4048✘✔
Example
A garden is m wide and m long, area 50 m²: Low, High between 5 and 6 m; a negative x is no width
x+3x50 m²

Exercises

Between which two whole numbers is the solution of ? Easy
Show solution
: , too low
: , too high
xx²20416<525>
Answer → between 4 and 5
Low turns into High: the solution is in between.
Between which two whole numbers is the solution of ? Easy
Show solution
: , too low
: , too high
xx³50327<464>
Answer → between 3 and 4
is a good next trial.
Solve to 1 decimal place. Medium
Show solution
Whole numbers: (low), (high)
Tenths: (low), (high)
44.554.44.5×10
The middle is too low, so the solution is in the upper half
4.44.454.5
Answer →
Without the middle test you could not be sure between 4.4 and 4.5.
Solve to 1 decimal place. Medium
Show solution
: 68 (low), : 130 (high)
: 95.625 (low), : 101.936 (high)
xx³+x1004.595.625<4.6101.936>
The middle 4.55 gives 98.746375: too low, so the upper half
4.54.554.6
Answer →
The solution is about 4.569, which rounds to 4.6.
Solve + 3x = 30 to 1 decimal place. Medium
Show solution
4.1: 29.11 (low), 4.2: 30.24 (high)
xx²+3x304.129.11<4.230.24>
The middle 4.15 gives 29.6725: too low, so the upper half
4.14.154.2
Answer →
The solution is about 4.18.
A cube-shaped box holds 300 cm³. How long is one edge, to 1 decimal place? Hard
xxx
Show solution
: (low), (high)
(low), (high)
xx³3006.6287.496<6.7300.763>
The middle is too low: the upper half
6.66.656.7
Answer → about 6.7 cm
Check: , close to 300.
Find the solutions of = 5x + 3 (about). Hard
Show solution
: 25 against 28, low. : 36 against 33, high: between 5 and 6
: 1 against −2, high. : 0 against 3, low: between −1 and 0
−224610203040xy
Answer → two solutions: one between 5 and 6 and one between −1 and 0
A table of whole numbers shows both sign changes.
Are you a teacher?

Start live lessons with these applications for your whole class. Free to try for one month.

Try it free

Fits these school years

IB (MYP, Diploma): MYP 4

Cambridge International: IGCSE

Netherlands: Year 2, Year 3 (havo, vwo), Havo · Mathematics A, Vwo · Mathematics A, Vmbo bb (years 3-4), Vmbo kb (years 3-4), Vmbo gt (years 3-4), Havo · Mathematics B, Vwo · Mathematics B, Vwo · Mathematics C

Türkiye (MEB): Year 8 (MEB), Year 9 (MEB)

England (GCSE, A Level): Year 9, Year 10 (GCSE), Year 11 (GCSE)

USA (Common Core): Grade 8, Algebra 1

What the applications of this topic teach 6 applications

Between which two numbers?

  • Telling if a trial is too low or too high
  • Finding two whole numbers around the solution of an equation
  • Seeing that an equation may have two solutions or none

Table and graph: zoom in

  • Reading a sign change in a table
  • Seeing the same solution as the crossing of two curves
  • Zooming in to find more decimals

Squeeze the solution

  • Trying numbers and improving the guess
  • Squeezing the solution between a Low and a High number
  • Giving the answer to 1, 2 or 3 decimal places

Digit by digit

  • Finding the solution one digit at a time
  • Knowing that every step makes the interval ten times smaller
  • Using the middle test to round correctly

Round the answer: test the middle

  • Knowing why between 4.4 and 4.5 is not yet an answer
  • Testing the middle and saying which half holds the solution
  • Knowing that a solution exactly in the middle is rounded up

Trial and improvement in everyday life

  • Using trial and improvement in a real situation
  • Saying which solutions fit the story
  • Giving a sensible answer: right decimals, whole years